Wednesday, December 9, 2009

Slides Three and Four: Conceptual Design

Our design choice for the PATO was the Stack Dispenser design. Here are some points as to why we chose this one over all the others:

Useful features:
  • Pill containers would allow some adjustability of dose size (several pills could be in each container)
  • Multiple dose types possible (a variety of pills could be placed in different stacks with different lockout times)

Main Advantages
Dimensions:
  • Lighter and smaller than both liquid dispensers
  • Smaller (better space optimization) than the strip dispenser and rotating pill dispenser

Simplicity:
  • Easier to work with solid pills or containers than with strips of material
  • Pills are readily available and plastic boxes are easily constructed, but more complex packaging of doses would be required for the strip dispenser

In more detail, the PATO uses the Stack Dispenser design because using pill containers would allow some dose adjustability, which was the major disadvantage of the stack dispenser. In other aspects (dimensions, simplicity, and affordability), the stack dispenser’s advantages were superior to those of the other designs. Overall, the advantages far outweighed the disadvantages of the design.

Dimensions:
The stack dispenser was superior to other designs in size and weight. Relying on rectangular tubes would use space much more efficiently than the rotating dispenser, which could only hold one ring of pills around the center without wasting space. The stack dispenser would weigh much less than the liquid analgesic dispensers once the weight of the analgesic was accounted for because the stack dispenser dispenses pills, whereas liquid dispensers would also have to hold the weight of the solvent. This would also make the liquid dispensers larger than necessary.

Simplicity:
It is much easier to work with solid pills or containers than with strips of material. Also, pills are readily available and plastic boxes are easily constructed, but more complex packaging of doses would be required for the strip dispenser. For these reasons, the strip dispenser was too complicated. The liquid dispensers were also more complex than the stack design. A hand-held pump could be unpredictable and inaccurate. The mechanism required to dispense one dose at a time from a syringe would be more complex than the simple process of releasing one pill. Finally, rotational motion is more complicated than linear motion. Thus the stack dispenser won out overall on simplicity. Simpler designs are cheaper to execute, so affordability is an added bonus.

Slide Two: Conceptual Design Options

Some of the different initial design ideas we had applied to a variety of different products, and although we had many more ideas, these are some cool ones.

Liquid Analgesic Dispenser:
  • Syringe-like dispenser: Liquid would be pushed out of one end of a syringe-type tube in precise quantities for the patient to collect and ingest. Pros: Precise and adjustable. Cons: Heavy, and restricted to a single analgesic.
  • Soap dispenser type pump: Patient would manually depress pump head. Pros: Cheap and easy to use. Cons: Heavy anRemove Formatting from selectiond Imprecise.Strip Tablet Dispenser:
Sheet Dispenser:
  • It would dispense analgesic strips similar to Listerine strips. Would function like a modified paper towel dispenser, where every time a button is pushed, one sheet is dispensed. Pros: Dose size adjustable. Cons: Too complex, requires analgesic strips similar to Listerine strips.
Solid Pill Dispenser
  • Rotating Dispenser: A wheel with prepackaged strips of pills in blisters would dispense them by rotating and cutting at a pre-perforated line. Pros: Ease of use Cons: Large and hard to design.
  • Stack Dispenser: Would be composed of several individual tubes, each with a stack of pills or pill containers. The bottom item of the stack would be dispensed laterally, and the rest of the stack would move down. Pros: simplicity, dose-holding capacity, affordability, variety of analgesics. Cons: limited adjustability of dose size.

Slide One: Specifications

To design the device, we had to address a series of specifications, for manufacturing companies as well as for physicians; i.e. say what we wanted our device to accomplish. These are some of the most important ideas we discussed:
  • Intended users: responsible adults and teenagers who are in pain and are deemed capable of controlling their dosing.
  • Functions and performance: dispense individual doses of analgesic upon request until a lockout time is reached, an emergency dose available and data storage.
  • Ease of use: very intuitive, featuring an LCD screen and few buttons, so that patients would push a single button to request a dose, and then confirm their decision.
  • Dimensions: 20x12x10cm, the weight would be under 5.5lbs(2.49kg); the LCD would be 9x7cm.
  • Operating conditions: it should be exposable to the sun, water resistant to a point, allow very high/low temperatures, pressures and other conditions.
  • Battery life: the battery should be long-lasting (at least 24h) and able to be plugged in to recharge.
  • Cost: it should cost under $400 to manufacture.
  • Lifetime: the device should have at least a 2-year life cycle.
  • Maintenance and repair: the only maintenance required should be charging it and refilling the pills. Repairing the battery and springs by professionals every so often would yield a longer life cycle.
  • Reliability and safety: should include a system so that only the patient can take the pills, a lock accessible only to physicians and pharmacists, a lockout time and emergency dose available. It should also inform the patient how many doses are left, and a code to activate refilling.
  • Ergonomics and appearance: it should be attachable to an IV pole, have no sharp edges and include a slide-out tray to allow patients to remove the pills easily.
  • Disposal: available only to hospitals and health-care centers for distribution to patients.

Monday, November 30, 2009

Detail Design

During the Detail Design week we determined the exact details that were left unfinished during the specifications process. For example, we created size and weight estimates: The device will be 20cm by 12 cm by 10 cm, enough to hold 4 rows of 5 tubes each, each tube 20cm tall and capable of holding 10 cubic 2cm boxes in a stack. This was the ideal set of dimensions for minimizing size while setting aside enough space for the pills and taking into consideration the limits of the constant force spring's extension. In this manner, we also determined in detail all other aspects of the device, like weight and cost.

We finalized the reloading mechanism as well. It was decided that magnets below each constant force spring and an electromagnet that could be turned on and off could be used for reloading. When the physician presses the reload button and enters the necessary code, the electromagnet will activate, attracting all the bar magnets to unwind all the springs. The physician can then unlock, open, and reload the device. When done, the physician can again press the reload button to deactivate the electromagnet.

Since last week, we changed our minds about the cell-phone like sliding technology due to the size and bulk of the device.

Sunday, November 22, 2009

Finalizing Specification

During last Thursday’s BE100 recitation DuckHunt design crew (Annie Conde, Anand Sundaram, and Daniel Chabolla) met to finalize the specification of the Patient-Controlled Oral Analgesia Device. Before moving any further with our design it was necessary to create specifications for the three feasible models that had been thought of during our first meeting session. Each member in our group was assigned one of the three models and became responsible for creating specifications for one particular device. After going over the specifications of the three devices and analyzing the pros and cons of each model, we decided that rather than settle for one of the three concepts, it would be wiser to bring together the best features of every device and craft a more efficient, functional, and stylish device.

Final specifications such as weight and size of the model haven't been determined just yet. At the moment, the DuckHunt crew is devising how to stack up and deliver the dosage in the most efficient manner. As foretold by Anand, it is very likely that the medication delivery system will function very similar to the way a stapler operates. The idea is that a spring will be compressing prepackaged doses of medication. The packages will be stacked vertically. At the opposite end of the compressing spring will be a motorized spring that will be extricating the prepackaged doses from their stacked up arrangement. We have yet to determine how we will refill the device; something that is likely to be determined during our next session. You can bet, though, that our device will have cell-phone slider technology and will be displaying an LCD screen.

Saturday, November 14, 2009

Conceptualizing

Before we begin to design anything, we need to brainstorm three conceptually different conceptual designs for a patient-controlled oral analgesic device. During Thursday's recitation, we came up with two viable concepts. One was a Pez-dispenser-like assembly line pill dispenser that could possibly function like a stapler (when you staple something, all the staples move down; similarly, all the pills would moved own in our device). The second was a liquid analgesic dispenser along the lines of a liquid hand soap dispenser. The main issue to be solved for both of these designs is security - how can one lock a patient out of using a soap dispenser? We need to design some mechanism to control the dispensation of analgesics in for both types of device.

We still need to come up with a third design concept. This should occur early next week. On Thursday, we cycled through several ideas only to dismiss them one by one. The one that generated the most conversation was the idea of making analgesics like Listerine strips, which would certainly look pretty cool.

Cheer up and check out some PEZ:
http://www.pez.com/v/default1.htm